You are here

Mass Firing of Texas Youth Commission Staff Makes National News --- But What about GEO Group's Past Record?

It's not the sort of national news story that any state agency wants --- the firing of 66 staffers of the Texas Youth Commission with previous felony convictions. But it reflects a typical double standard, as individuals are dealt with harshly, while a corporation gets to keep on with business as usual, in spite of their horrible record of problems and abuse.

Geo Group's Coke County Juvenile lockup may not be the absolute worst of the Texas Youth Commission (TYC) scandal, but their problems reach back far and pretty deep, and it would be a shame for TYC to not address them while they are in the public eye.

Geo Group already had a notorious record when it won the contract with TYC. Then GEO Group was allowed to keep its contract even after the horrible 2000 lawsuit for sexual abuse of a girl named Sara Lowe in their custody that revealed widespread problems at Coke County Juvenile. An employee with a past sex offense conviction had abused and then stalked the girl, 11 other girls reported abuse, and in other incidents, two employees pled guilty to sexual assault. As a result of the suit, Coke County Juvenile stopped housing girls. But the story ended tragically, with Sara Lowe's suicide the day of the settlement.

With a record like that, you would think GEO Group would be worried about how they're going to weather this shake-up at TYC that's dealing with the employees of Texas Youth Commission so harshly. But with thousands of reports of abuse, misconduct and poor conditions at youth prisons across Texas, Coke County Juvenile is managing to stay out of the headlines (sometimes), maybe because they are not the absolute worst Texas youth prison.... For example, of over 2,000 reports of medical care problems across the state, Coke County Juvenile ranks sixth in complaints, with 95 reports of poor medical care, -- more than most, but again, not the absolute worst of the bunch. And Coke County Juvenile has only made recent headlines for firing one employee with a previous felony conviction --- an employee with a juvenile conviction for exposing himself to another child. So, yes, there are other now-former TYC employees with more serious charges, but some of their past convictions are not clearly ones that should get them fired.

And maybe some of those folks with 20-year old felony convictions were well-suited to do corrections work. Many people who turn their lives around after a felony conviction can make outstanding role models and advocates for people in conflict with the law. But Jay Kimbrough, the conservator of TYC right now, only agreed to temper his "no felons: period" approach after legislators pointed out that some previous felony convictions don't always present a problem for working in corrections. It makes sense to take into account the circumstances of their past and their overall performance in the workplace. Once you've done an evaluation like that, sure, some of these folks should not be working in corrections, especially not with youth.

And similarly, corporations like GEO Group, and their Coke County Juvenile lock-up, should also be evaluated based on their record. Geo group's Coke County Juvenile may not be the absolute worst right now, but it has a lengthy record and it's right in the middle of the scandals at TYC. Maybe there are concerns about cancelling GEO's lucrative contract, since they have been known to sue you if you cancel their contract. But given their long history of poor conditions and scandalous abuse, maybe it's time to get GEO Group out of the Texas youth prison business, and get Coke County Juvenile prison cleaned up along with the rest of TYC.

Blogging Categories: 


"But it reflects a typical double standard, as individuals are dealt with harshly, while a corporation gets to keep on with business as usual, in spite of their horrible record of problems and abuse."

Except in this case they didn't. TYC cancelled the GEO contract that year.

It's true that TYC did cancel the Coke County contract in October of 2007, 5 months after this was posted, and after allegations of neglect and filth came out in the TYC ombudsman's report.  In fact, GEO has had 5 contracts canceled in the past 4 years in Texas alone.  That said, the company continues to win other contracts around the state and continues to perform miserably, so the question remains - what kind of accountability is there for this company?